Supervisor Ed Smyth told Newsday it was "mathematically impossible" to keep current programs and services in 2027 without piercing the state tax cap. On October 2, 2026, the Town of Huntington released a $269.7 million tentative budget that would raise the town tax levy from about $143.5 million to about $169.9 million, an increase of about 18.3%. Newsday reported that the town last pierced the cap in 2017 and that the allowable increase this year was 2.68%.
For a buyer comparing houses across the town, the 18% figure is easy to misread. It refers to the proposed increase in the town's tax levy. School districts and assessments also affect a buyer's annual carrying cost. New York State says the assessment roll was last fully reassessed "Prior to 1974."
Eighteen Percent of a Small Slice
A Huntington property tax bill combines several separate levies: school, library, county, county police, town, highway, fire, lighting and other districts. The town explains that the overall rate blends the school tax, the library tax and a "combined code" that can include county, town, highway, fire, lighting, open-space and refuse charges.
The town's own 2027 Preliminary Budget Book breaks down how 2025/26 bills were divided in each of the eight school districts within the town.
| School district | School share | Town share | Highway share | Town + Highway |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cold Spring Harbor | 66.4% | 5.9% | 3.4% | 9.3% |
| Commack | 70.3% | 6.3% | 2.9% | 9.2% |
| Elwood | 68.6% | 6.6% | 3.0% | 9.6% |
| Half Hollow Hills | 65.8% | 6.9% | 3.5% | 10.4% |
| Harborfields | 65.0% | 6.9% | 3.1% | 10.0% |
| Huntington | 64.9% | 7.7% | 3.4% | 11.1% |
| Northport | 62.9% | 8.0% | 3.6% | 11.6% |
| South Huntington | 67.9% | 7.5% | 3.2% | 10.7% |
In 2025/26, school taxes took between 62.9% and 70.3% of the bill. The town and highway lines together took between 9.2% and 11.6%. Newsday put the town's estimate in household terms: about $25 more per month for the average town homeowner.
The budget book gives a second figure. It shows the combined tax levy for the town's "Four Major Funds" (General, Highway, Refuse District and Part-Town) rising by $25.3 million, or 19.94%. That figure covers a different set of funds than the 18.3% total-levy figure reported by Newsday, so expect both numbers to appear in coverage between now and adoption.
Where the House Sits Changes the Exposure
The table also shows that the same town budget weighs differently from one school district to the next. A Northport-district bill carried a 2025/26 town share of 8.0%, compared with 5.9% in Cold Spring Harbor. Fire district charges vary widely too, from 2.3% of the bill in the Commack column to 6.2% in Cold Spring Harbor. Water district charges are 0.0% in some districts and up to 1.6% in others.
A buyer looking at a house near Centerport and another near Dix Hills is comparing two different stacks of taxing jurisdictions, not two homes under one town rate. The school levy is the largest piece in every column.
How a Pre-1974 Roll Divides the Pie
The second mechanism decides how each levy gets split among individual homeowners. The town assessor states that an assessment "represents a fraction, or a percentage, of the market value," which is why Huntington assessments are typically small numbers. The town's 2026 Residential Assessment Ratio is .39%. Its own worked example divides an assessment of 4,100 by .0039 and arrives at an indicated market value of $1,051,282.
New York State's reassessment guidance describes what happens when a roll goes years without a full update. Some properties become over-assessed and others under-assessed, because market values move at different speeds while assessments stay put. The state's example puts it directly: "Property C is actually subsidizing the tax bill of Property A." The same page compares the total levy to a pie. Elected boards decide its size, and the assessment roll only decides how it is cut.
The state also notes that an equalization rate measures the overall level of assessment across a municipality and does not correct inequities between individual parcels. So the annually adjusted .39% ratio does nothing to bring individual homes into line with one another. Each year's bigger or smaller levy is spread across assessments that have drifted apart for decades.
Assessment History and Property Tax Bills
Two houses listed near the same price on similar lots can carry very different bills, because each carries its own assessment history.
Huntington's process for challenging an assessment, called a grievance, runs once a year. The town's grievance page says the grievance period for the 2026/2027 tax year has closed and procedures for 2027/2028 will be posted in April 2027. For the cycle that just ended, the town asked owners to estimate what the property would have sold for on July 1, 2025, using a recent sale, an appraisal or a comparative market analysis.
The Dates From the Hearing to the Tax Bills
Newsday, Huntington Now and the town's own budget calendar all list the hearing for November 5. The levy figure stays a proposal until the board votes:
- November 5, 6 p.m.: Public hearing on the tentative budget at Town Hall, 100 Main Street.
- November 17: Adoption date on the town's budget calendar. Newsday reported that a budget must be approved by November 20.
- Mid-December: Tax bills mailed. The town's tax year runs December 1 through November 30.
Smyth told Newsday that board members are "welcome to present resolutions reducing the budget" over the five weeks before adoption. Council members Brooke Lupinacci and Jen Hebert voted against the September resolution that allowed the cap to be pierced. The 18.3% figure could still change before November 17.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the proposed 18% increase apply to? The proposed increase applies to the town's levy. In 2025/26, the town and highway lines together made up between 9.2% and 11.6% of a bill, depending on the school district. School, county, library and district levies are set separately.
On any home we represent, a buyer's carrying cost is part of the underwriting, not an afterthought. Kieran Rodgers and Team Rodgers pull the current assessment and the school and special-district breakdown for the specific parcel. Schedule your private consultation on any Huntington home you're weighing.