A quiet living-room corner with a cream cast-iron radiator beneath a window, a gray armchair and wool throw, and late-autumn greenery outside.

What It Costs to Heat a Centerport House This Winter

In October 2025, heating oil delivered on Long Island averaged $3.849 a gallon. In October 2026 it averaged $6.338, according to NYSERDA's regional price survey for Nassau and Suffolk. That is roughly 65% higher in one year. Over the same months, the gas supply charge on a National Grid bill fell from its spring peak.

A larger share of Centerport's homes heat with oil than in any nearby community, so the split reaches a bigger part of its housing. If you are comparing houses here this winter, the fuel line on the utility history now separates two similar listings more than it has in years. Switching a house to a different fuel depends on the specific address and takes months, so the question belongs in the offer stage, before closing.

Two in Five Centerport Homes Run on Oil

The Census Bureau's American Community Survey 5-year estimates for 2020 through 2024 put about 39.5% of Centerport's occupied homes on fuel oil or kerosene and 55.1% on utility gas. Those shares come from table B25040, which counts occupied housing units. The nearby communities sit lower on oil:

Community Fuel oil or kerosene Utility gas Electricity
Centerport 39.5% 55.1% 4.2%
Greenlawn 36.5% 49.5% 12.2%
Northport 31.1% 59.5% 3.9%
Huntington 30.4% 58.2% 6.8%

The survey estimates about 893 oil-heated homes in Centerport over that 2020 to 2024 window. In a market this small, one buyer's shortlist can easily hold an oil house and a gas house at nearly the same price. Last winter the gap between them was a modest line item. This winter it is larger.

Why Oil Climbed While Gas Eased

Oil prices began rising early in 2026. In March, Newsday tied the surge to the U.S.-Israel war with Iran, shipping disruption in the Strait of Hormuz and damage to Middle Eastern oil and gas facilities. NYSERDA's October 9, 2026 market report listed the Iran war among global pressures and said regional ultra-low-sulfur diesel inventories were still below their 10-year range. Heating oil and diesel are close cousins. New York on-road diesel was $6.520 a gallon on October 2, 2026, compared with $3.903 a year earlier.

Prices stayed high into the heating season. Newsday reported a Long Island weekly average of $6.37 a gallon in late October 2026, 67% above the prior year's $3.82, and put one full 250-gallon delivery at $1,592.50, the price of a single fill in a season that usually needs several.

Gas went the other way. National Grid's residential gas supply charge on Long Island fell to 47.67 cents a therm in September 2026 after reaching 96.5 cents in March, according to a Newsday report from September. For November 2026, National Grid lists the residential supply charge at $0.510971 a therm. Delivery charges are separate, under a schedule that took effect April 1, 2026. The same October Newsday report relayed National Grid's projection that a typical customer's November-through-March bills will total about $1,461, a net increase of about $5 over last winter.

The federal forecast shows the same split. The U.S. Energy Information Administration's Winter Fuels Outlook, published October 6, 2026, projects that heating-oil households nationwide will spend 21% more this winter, about $2,115 on average. It projects Northeast households heating with natural gas will spend $879, down 14%, and Northeast households heating with electricity will spend $1,637, down 3%. These are averages across different groups of homes. They do not show what one house would pay on each fuel, and the EIA says home size, efficiency, equipment and weather all change the result.

Whether a House Can Switch Depends on the Address

The obvious response to an oil listing is to plan a conversion to gas. In Centerport, whether that is possible depends on the house. National Grid's Long Island conversion guide tells homeowners to call 1-877-MyNGrid to find out how far their home is from a gas line. A September Newsday report included an oil customer nearby on the North Shore who could not convert because gas was not available where he lives. Two houses a few blocks apart can get different answers from the utility.

Where gas is available, the utility's guide estimates 12 to 14 weeks to install a service line, 14 to 16 weeks when a main is also needed, and another 4 to 6 weeks when the work is on a state or county road. The guide is dated September 2024, so ask National Grid for current timing on the specific property.

A buyer who closes in January on an oil-heated house and starts a conversion that month would, using the guide's estimates, finish a main-and-service job in April or May at the earliest. That buyer pays for this winter's heat at this winter's oil prices whatever the long-term plan is. A conversion is a decision for next winter and should be valued that way.

Heat pumps are the third option, and electricity costs have moved less. PSEG Long Island's power supply charge for November 2026 is $0.142906 per kilowatt-hour, 2.7% above October. PSEG Long Island's heat pump rebate page lists $4,000 for a whole-house system in a market-rate single-family home, along with larger amounts in other categories. Like a gas conversion, this is a project with a contractor and a lead time, not something that changes a bill in the first month.

Putting the Fuel Line Into an Offer

On a Centerport house tour this season, the heating system is a cost question you can answer before making an offer, and three things help.

First, ask for the house's actual fuel history: oil delivery receipts or gas and electric bills, covering at least one full winter. Most of last winter's oil was bought at much lower prices. NYSERDA's Long Island monthly averages ran from $3.849 in October 2025 to $4.346 in February 2026 before reaching $5.50 in March 2026. The same number of gallons costs far more at October 2026's $6.338.

Second, call National Grid about the specific address before you decide how much to pay for "convertible to gas." A gas main in front of the house is worth something. A main several hundred feet away means a quote and a season of waiting.

Third, if you will be buying oil, line up a dealer early. Dole Fuel Oil, at 100 New York Avenue in Huntington, lists Centerport, Northport, Greenlawn and East Northport in its North Shore service area and has both automatic delivery and cash-on-delivery service.

A seller of an oil-heated Centerport house can answer these questions before buyers ask them. Gather the delivery records, and get National Grid's answer on gas availability ahead of listing. The house may also have other systems a buyer will want documented, as our earlier post on how septic records affect Centerport sale timelines covers. Documents like these make the conversation shorter.

The prices and programs above are dated figures from public sources, offered as general information and not as financial or tax advice. Confirm the numbers for a specific property with the utility, your contractor and your own advisors.

If you are comparing Centerport houses this winter and want each one's heating system, fuel history and gas availability factored into what you offer, Kieran Rodgers and Team Rodgers can work through the numbers with you, address by address. Schedule Your Private Consultation.

Work With Kieran

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram